FEED Magazine
RE: Christopher Hitchens
<b>Christopher Hitchens</b> has accused Henry Kissinger of war crimes. He talks to Matthew Craft about the fallout.

CHRISTOPHER HITCHENS is a journalist who charts his own course, regardless of public opinion. As a columnist for Vanity Fair and The Nation, Hitchens has earned a reputation for his biting wit and irreverent positions. In all the pique and fury that surrounded President Clinton in 1998, many liberals and most of Hitchens's colleagues at The Nation came to Clinton's defense. But Hitchens turned out scathing but detailed essays picking apart what he called the president's "ruthless vanity," the shady business deals, and the hasty bombing of Sudan, among other offenses. These formed the extended argument that was his best-selling book, No One Left to Lie To.
Hitchens is, plainly, a throwback, closer in spirit to a polemicist like Thomas Paine than to the modern reporter. One of his celebrated targets was the woman whom he nicknamed "the ghoul of Calcutta," familiar to many as the late Mother Theresa. His slim book about her bore the cringe-inducing title "The Missionary Position." He exposed her as a shill for despots such as Jean-Claude Duvalier, and criticized her fight against abortion and contraception. This "hell's angel" hoarded millions upon millions in donations while enforcing harsh poverty on both the dying and the nuns who worked in her missions.
Hitchens has most recently set his crosshairs on the �minence grise of the foreign policy establishment. In a series of essays in Harper's entitled "The Case Against Henry Kissinger," he argues that the national security adviser and secretary of state under Nixon and Ford ought to be prosecuted for war crimes for his role in assassinations, occupations, and executions in Indochina, Chile, Bangladesh, East Timor, and Cyprus.

The most devastating charges relate to Kissinger's involvement in Chile and, particularly, Vietnam. Hitchens makes the case that in 1968, Kissinger took part in an effort by the Nixon campaign to undermine the negotiations between the North and South Vietnamese governments, which were, at the time, close to an agreement. Nixon's team told the South Vietnamese that they would receive a better deal under a Republican presidency. The South Vietnamese backed out of the talks, undermining Hubert Humphrey's 1968 campaign and continuing the war. "The subversion of that election and the prolonging of that war," Hitchens said, make it "the single wickedest act in the history of the republic."
He also contends that Kissinger "bears direct responsibility" for murdering the chief of the Chilean army, General Rene Schneider, in 1970 as part of the CIA's effort to prevent Salvador Allende from assuming office.
In the course of a recent conversation on these essays and his upcoming book on the same subject, Hitchens described Kissinger as "a murderer, a liar, a pseudo-intellectual, a thief of government property, and a profiteer from said theft." Bold though these words might seem, Hitchens's indictment is buttressed by White House memos, FBI files, and recently released CIA cables. There are many other documents that could give a fuller picture of his actions, but Kissinger took most of his papers and put them in the Library of Congress, where, according to an agreement, they are safe from the public's gaze until he dies.


FEED: For someone who hasn't read your piece in Harpers, can you point to something Kissinger did that sums up your case against him? What's most egregious?
HITCHENS: Well, I think that his very intimate micromanaging of the plan to kill General Rene Schneider in Chile is what, from a legal point of view, you could say is the best case. Here's a guy who, in a very squalid and sadistic manner, has taken the life of an honorable conservative in another country with which the United States had no quarrel. And I think in a way that's still the most shocking single incidence.
FEED: Is it realistic to think that he could actually wind up in the dock for it?
HITCHENS: Well, he'll suffer some inconvenience for it now that all the facts are in. He'll have to. But I can tell you another thing relevant to this -- he won't suffer any inconvenience in his own mind. If he read that record, I don't think that it would make him feel queasy. He might feel insulted or annoyed that I brought it up. But he wouldn't think, "Gee, did I really do that?"
But it's also rather a micro case in some ways. The macro thing definitely would be his participation in the undermining of the elections of '68 with the understanding that this was renewing the mortgage on a war that he knew was lost. At the very least was lost. And in both cases for short-term personal gain.
FEED: But would there be strong grounds for a legal case?
HITCHENS: Yeah. The Logan Act [which prohibits Americans from conducting private diplomacy with a foreign country] would be the first thing. It's illegal to do that under the Logan Act. I don't know what the statute of limitations is there, but I'm sure an action could lie under that.
FEED: Given what you've said about how people don't want to hear that they've been duped, do you think there's popular support for such a case?
HITCHENS: There's duping and there's duping. Some people do the duping to themselves. They say things like, "Well, he brought down taxes, even if he was a thief." But in the case of the '68 events, they simply didn't know. That gang -- the Nixon-Mitchell-Agnew-Kissinger gang -- flattered the American people in this way: They never told them the truth. They fed them a fantastic diet of lies. It is a compliment to the American public that it was never believed of them by their political-criminal leadership that if they knew the truth, they would accept it. So, in this case they weren't duped. They just had no idea. The people who did know in the Johnson administration and in the FBI, and the people who conducted the wire taps and surveillance, were so horrified by it that they didn't think it could be made public without creating a semirevolutionary situation.
But among those duped are the families and survivors of 22,500 American citizens who lost their lives in that period. I would be reluctant to say these people have been fooled. That would be an insult to them. I think that it might be too much for them to face. But some of them know very well. Quite independent of anything I say, that fact demands justice.
FEED: A friend of mine was in the middle of reading your piece, and he said, "This Hitchens guy. He's pretty biased isn't he?" He said that the tone of it was so strong, it's as if you weren't giving Kissinger his due.
HITCHENS: I think that's an exceptionally fatuous objection. In the first place, you have to look at the cover to see that this is the presentation of the case against Henry Kissinger. To discover this by reading it seems to me a kind of work of what the Anglicans used to call supererogation In other words, a surplus of requirements. A more measured response would perhaps be to say, "Well, he sure is making a case. I wonder what the response to that would be? I wonder what the reply is?"
And I'm awaiting the answer to that question myself, because I've dangled it in front of [Kissinger]. We solicited responses from all his usual defenders and we haven't heard anything yet.
FEED: Like whom?
HITCHENS: We've approached Lawrence Eagleburger and Brent Scowcroft and Peter Rodman and all those foreign policy types who've worked with Kissinger, or who generally rise to his defense. They won't come. They won't say. They won't do anything. And I've also approached the people in the press who I know are sympathetic to him. People like NPR, who've had me on, have looked high and low for people to come on and take his side, and so far, no one. Which I should say is a disappointment to me, because it would be nice to have something to chew on.


FEED: There's been no response from Kissinger, or Kissinger Associates?
HITCHENS: No, absolutely none whatever. Well, except to our second letter, which was when they refused to reply to our first one, saying, "We'd like to ask you some questions." I wrote again and said: "Look, I hope it's not a matter of money. Perhaps I should be the one to break the ice here. I mean if you feel that we should offer you a fee, then by all means. We're not rich. But perhaps we could pay you as much as, say, Ted Koppel would for an average Nightline, because I'm sure that in that time I would be able to ask the main questions I want to ask you, that you've never been asked by Mr. Koppel."
And that got us a sort of hurt, tear-stained response from William Rodgers, his deputy, saying, "How dare you?" And I wrote back, saying, "I never knew before that Kissinger regarded an offer of money as offensive. But I'm pleased to have this assurance."
FEED: What questions would you ask him?
HITCHENS: I would ask: "When you decided to commission and pay for and arm the murders of General Schneider, did you feel you needed congressional authorization? Did you seek it, and did you feel that you had presidential authorization?"
"When you were in the room with the generals in Indonesia the day before they invaded East Timor, what did you say?" He's never been asked that, you know. It's amazing that -- how many journalists are there in Washington and New York who specialize in foreign affairs? A lot. He's never been asked this stuff.
Those are the sorts of questions I would ask. They would not be arm-waving questions. They'd be forensic, based on what I already know.
Of course, the ideal thing would be if they sued.
FEED: For libel?
HITCHENS: Yeah. But I don't believe for a moment that they will. They wouldn't be able to endure the discovery phase. They would have to disclose documents that they must be terrified of disclosing. If you look at those Chilean documents that we now do have and look at what they admit to, and then you look at the blacked-out bits, you think, "Well, boy, given what they've owned up to in the unredacted parts, what the hell could that be?"
It's a consistent thing: Every time documents are disclosed, they only confirm what you suspected. It never leads you away from the hypothesis that the existing documents give you. So, the induction from that is that what they're holding must be very incriminating indeed.
It's also impossible to imagine that Henry Kissinger is sitting on a whole pile of documents that would clear his name. With fairly high confidence, I'd certainly challenge him to see me in court.
FEED: A few weeks ago Walter Isaacson [the editor of Time magazine and author of Kissinger: A Biography] spoke at Columbia's Journalism School, and he said, "You know everyone loves Hitchens, but he's a little extreme. He takes things too far."
HITCHENS: I should say I not only think that [Isaacson's] book is good, in many ways, but I rely on it. But I describe it as overly lenient. And one of the reasons that I have for that is that I've always thought that the thread of the Schneider assassination, if you pull it out, it never stops pulling until the whole thing is unraveled. Walter's book, using almost the same evidence as I did, managed to come to a conclusion that was completely, logically, and morally false -- that it's just an episode in the destabilization of Chile, it isn't really a murder attempt.
Now we know that you can't say that anymore. Last fall we discovered that the CIA had paid a large sum of money in cash to the killers of Schneider after they had done the job. That's flat out aiding and abetting, an accomplice, an accessory -- all of that. It makes nonsense of all the other interpretations. But Walter somehow managed to guess what was missing, because he's not a fool, and to make it sound less than it really was. But what he likes to think is that Kissinger didn't like his book -- and it's certainly not a toadying book -- but now he's getting attacked from left and right. People like him love to be able to say that, because it makes them seem that they're thoughtful, responsible. Well, I'm impatient with that kind of complacency, I must say.


FEED: When people dismiss your work they say, "Well, he's the same guy who attacked Mother Theresa." And when the Clinton book came out there were a few reviews implying that you were sort of poisoned by your hatred of the man, so you weren't seeing it clearly.
HITCHENS: I think one ought to suspect the motives of people who faced with, say, a suggestion that Bill Clinton as president was not on the level, that he was a crook and he used the office principally to enrich himself and his friends and to commit other offenses, if you take the trouble to make that case and produce your evidence, there will be those who say, "Let's leave that for now while we talk about the author of these allegations." It's one of the things that I look for as a sign that I must be onto something, because people don't try to change the subject if they're happy to discuss it. What I've been doing over the last ten years or so is basically trying to show that American liberalism has become extremely decayed if not corrupt. They've had to swallow so much bit by bit about Clinton that they of course had no choice but to try and change the subject.
FEED: I think that confuses a lot of people who follow American politics. They don't know what to make of someone who attacks Bill Clinton and attacks people on the right.
HITCHENS: You might say that Kissinger is an attack on the right, but that wouldn't quite be right, because a lot of conservatives have always disliked and distrusted him for good reasons. And the second thing is that when I go out of my way to try and show what the implications are -- if what I say about Kissinger is true -- I say that the people who have to feel most embarrassed are the American press and the American human rights community for deliberately ignoring this or for shielding themselves from its implications. So, again, this is an attack on the reigning liberal culture. They're the ones who have actually let him off and flattered him. Of course it's an attack on the Nixon administration and the crooks who were involved in that. And the killers, too. It isn't an attack on the political right in this country in its implications at all.
FEED: Where do you stand politically?
HITCHENS: I don't have any identifiable political allegiance at the moment, though I'm barely ready even to say that. My political training and allegiance was with the left, and I'm sure it shows. That's how I learned to argue and what to look for. But that of course came from the particular left tradition that was so involved in a lot of argument within the left, when there was such a thing as an intra-left argument, which there hardly is anymore.
FEED: I remember Brian Lamb on C-Span used to ask you, "Are you still a socialist?"
HITCHENS: I was very glad he didn't do that the other day when I went on with him. He used to begin every time we came on. I knew he hoped that one day I'd say, "Okay, okay, you win." And I knew that even if that day ever came I wouldn't be glad that it had. It's a question I'm quite happy to postpone at the moment. It doesn't condition anything I do anymore. I would certainly say that.

Matthew Craft is a graduate student at Columbia University. He was a newspaper reporter for three years and his work has appeared in Counterpunch.

Other articles by Matthew Craft

Back to Article