Interview | 02.16.01 RE: Warren Spector
continued from page 1...
FEED: Most of the games you've done have been narrative-driven rather than "pure" action games. And, in a lot of ways, the ability to tell a story, to build a complex narrative in System Shock 1, Deus Ex, etc., has been one of the things that have separated your games from the pack. Can you talk a bit about the role of narrative in your games? WARREN SPECTOR: I've always been into stories and storytelling, but until you asked this question I never stopped to think about the fact that I've never made a game that wasn't driven by narrative concerns. Actually, though, that's too simple a way to look at it. For me, the interesting thing has always been the tension between a story that we, the developers, create and the ways in which players participate in the telling of that story. The dialogue between creator and player is fascinating to me... FEED: Do you see storytelling as the driving force in game design for you? SPECTOR: I'm coming around to the idea that there are multiple levels to any narrative. There's the overall story arc -- the big events, accelerating tensions, major plot twists, character growth, and so on -- that have been the mainstay of traditional, linear narrative since the days of Aristotle. And then there are the myriad minute-to-minute events that weave together the elements of the overall story arc. If you listen to a description of the typical pen-and-paper D&D campaign or to a description of a player's magic moments while playing a computer game, you get none of the big story arc stuff and lots of events -- "We did this and then we did that and then something happened and I killed the evil bad guy..."  Do I really need to say that makes for a personally meaningful but ultimately uninteresting narrative? I suspect that's why even the best fiction based on roleplaying campaigns or computer games is invariably bad. Most people excel at minute-to-minute event-description but ninety-nine percent of them aren't very good at the Big Picture. That's why there are very few authors in the world, or filmmakers, and lots of readers and viewers. What I want to do, at least until someone comes up with a better idea, is to provide the skeleton of a story -- the powerful, traditional narrative arc -- while leaving players in complete control of the minute-to-minute. Players can and should own their highly personalized story, but the overall arc belongs to the developers. Put another way, it's possible -- and, I think, desirable -- to leave what players do in our hands while leaving the how of it in their hands. Confront players with problems, I say, but let them decide how to solve them. The what provides a rich emotional context for action; the how allows for maximum player expression and generates the kind of highly personal, event-driven story that only gaming can provide. I love the dialogue between players and creators this approach forces. But, then again, a lot of my friends and colleagues think I'm completely wrong about all this so who can say? FEED: So how do you balance the competing demands of gameplay and narrative? Or are they really in conflict at all? SPECTOR: There's a cliché among game developers about narrative and games being like two ends of a teeter-totter -- the more you emphasize narrative, the more you tip over toward one side of the teeter-totter, the less game-like your work becomes. Conversely, the more game-like you make your work, the less relevant traditional narrative concerns become. There's certainly some truth to that, but what the cliché doesn't get at is the fact that a teeter-totter isn't a binary thing -- it's not an on/off switch. It's a dynamic system and so, I think, should narrative games be. Something doesn't have to be all game or all narrative. And there's no reason why the teeter-totter can't shift back and forth, the balance shifting to meet players' needs -- and to satisfy developers' creative urges. FEED: You were working on a Ph.D. in film theory before you got into games. Has that shaped your approach to doing game design? SPECTOR: Yeah. I was working on my doctorate in radio-TV-film and did a lot of work in history, theory, and criticism. I don't know that my background shaped my approach to gaming, really. I mean, I certainly had a lot of things to unlearn, coming from a well-established, linear medium to one defined by its nonlinearity and still trying to find its own conventions! I guess it never hurts to know something about traditional narrative forms and aesthetics and semiotics and all. But, really, the most valuable thing anyone gets out of grad school is something that would stand you in good stead in any field -- you learn how to think. As an undergrad, you get your head filled with lots of facts and, if you're lucky, you find a prof or two who force you to take a step further. Grad school, at least in my experience, was all about "further steps." You pick up on analytical tools that can be applied to just about anything. I also learned that there was value in applying analytical tools to things that most people consider beneath analysis -- I mean, try telling your mother you're writing your dissertation on television melodrama and see what happens. It ain't pretty. Anyway, I think grad school gave me a way of looking at the world that clearly affects the way I approach everything in my life, not just game development. I'm not sure there's any one-to-one correlation between studying film and making games. FEED: 3-D gaming is only a few years old, still in it's infancy, really, and lots of people in the field say that you should think how far it's already come compared to film in its early days. But it seems like gaming is already running on a late-capitalist-culture-industry economic model the drive toward blockbusters (and the attendant huge production budgets), the emphasis on sequels, the iron control of publisher's marketing departments, etc. Gaming, in a way, went from being a garage craft (like video in its early, utopian days) to being a Hollywood-style system in nothing flat. And you've been able to watch that transformation from the inside. What's that been like for you? Has that change affected the kinds of games you think about making? Or the kinds of creative decisions you make? SPECTOR: Ouch. Tough question! Like all things in this computer-driven age, gaming is developing at a far faster rate than earlier media. It's partly a result of constantly and rapidly changing technology, you know, when hardware doubles in power every six months, you adapt and change, quickly, or you don't survive. But the business developments you're talking about may also stem from the fact that we have business models to crib from TV and movies, as you correctly point out, where the earlier media had no models. We (or, I should say, the publishers) can look at how Hollywood does business and say, "Hey, why don't we try that?" So they give it a shot. Honestly, though, I'm not sure I see any alternative. I mean, once someone spends five million dollars or ten million dollars or more on a game and succeeds in the marketplace, it's tough to get players to accept lower quality graphics or sound or acting or whatever. We all have to follow along, to some extent. Business practices don't just arrive fully formed from the brow of some clueless executive somewhere (evidence to the contrary notwithstanding!). Businesses follow the money and the money follows player expectations. And what players expect right now is high production values and lots of content, which costs a lot of money. So, here we are in an era of increasing development costs, ridiculous marketing costs, and relatively stagnant sales. You have a couple of whopper hits, a handful of successes and a bunch (a BUNCH) of failures. That leads to consolidation, fewer and fewer independent developers, less innovation, more sequels, etc., etc., etc. Kind of ugly, really.
|